Literature Review On Community Intervention Health And Social Care Essay

Published: 2020-07-03 14:56:05
3464 words
13 pages
printer Print
essay essay

Category: Health

Type of paper: Essay

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Hey! We can write a custom essay for you.

All possible types of assignments. Written by academics

Primary attention or community based intercessions for childhood fleshiness – which puting shows most promise: a reappraisal of two randomized control ; multi-component experimental tests. Obesity is a clinical status which defines when an person ‘s organic structure fat is in surplus of that which is considered optimum for wellness and is a taking cause of preventable sick wellness in both grownups and kids worldwide ( IASO, 2010 ; WHO, 2011a ) . Long term effects possibly physical, psychological and economic ( Pinhas-Hamiel & A ; Zeitler, 2000 ; IASO, 2010 ) and current estimations indicate 40-50 million school kids are corpulent ( IASO/IOTF, 2010 )
Figure 1: Increasing Overweight in Children around the World ( Foresight, 2007 )
Whilst fleshiness is lifting worldwide ( figure 1 ) , its societal patterning in the UK is altering ( PHRC, 2008 ) . In the 1958 birth cohort and their kids, there was n’t a societal gradient, but, the Millennium Cohort survey has identified that societal differences are emerging most markedly between the ne’er worked/long term unemployed and higher societal groups ( PHRC, 2008 ) . The aetiology of fleshiness is in kernel an instability between energy consumption ( higher ) and outgo ( lower ) , nevertheless, this basic cause and consequence statement does non account for the complex web of social and biological factors that have, in recent decennaries, exposed our built-in human exposure to burden addition ” . ( National Obesity Observatory from Foresight study, 2011 ) Covering with this job, is a important challenge, NICE guidelines ( 2006 ) urge multi-component activity, nutrient and behavioral intercessions.
Figure 2: Fleshiness systems map. ( Foresight, 2007 p.89 )
Following a systematic appraisal of the literature 13 documents were identified for more in deepness assessment against concluding inclusion testing standards detailed in appendix 2 ensuing in two selected for comparing. A sum-up of the two documents can be seen in figure 3. They matched each other comparatively closely and had a strong plenty design ( i.e RCT ) , and theoretical footing and met NICE counsel[ 1 ]on multi-component plans. The intercessions were delivered in two different scenes over a similar length for intercession and followup ( ~ 15 months ) .
The theories underpinning the intercessions were both cognitive-behavioural in attack, aiming alteration at the single degree mediated at the degree of the household unit. They besides both integrated physical activity and nutritionary constituents. Studies reviewed:
McCallum et Al, 2008 ( Live, Eat and Play: LEAP )
Sacher et Al, 2010 ( Mind, Exercise, Nutrition Do it: MEND )
The intercessions were delivered in different scenes GP/Primary attention versus community but, both had roots in societal cognitive theory ; LEAP, with the usage of end scene and awards ( positive support ) and MEND which used stimulation control, support and end scene as portion of the behavioral constituent, therefore holding the potency to better motive, continuity and assurance on end attainment However there were differences, the behavioral intercession in LEAP used a psychotherapeutic counselling/brief intercession ( 4 GP audiences ) and written household support stuffs including seven behavioral undertaking sheets ( attachment to utilize of stuffs was non reported ) . MEND nevertheless, provided 8 hours dedicated to behavioral alteration, supported by 16 exercise/play and 8 nutrition instruction Sessionss including a visit to a supermarket and nutrient readying activities, all offering merriment modelling/’echoic ” ( Skinner, 1957 ) chances in a supportive environment. In this sense combined environmental, personal and behavioral constituents offered a more all-around societal cognitive behavior alteration intercession, than LEAP which was focussed on a solution focussed curative procedure utilizing end setting/reinforcement awards ” ( Greenberg et al, 2001 ) as a short behavior alteration tool.
Consequences: BMI ( kg/m2 ) was the chief result of involvement and alterations in nutrition and physical/sedentary activity when comparing the intercessions effectiveness ; whilst BMI was non the primary result in MEND it was reported appropriately to utilize for this intent here.
Figure 3: article reappraisal tabular array captured from appendix1.
When sing longitudinal alteration [ up to 12 months ] MEND is reported otherwise than LEAP as MEND merely maintained a control group for 6 months, the original controls crossed over into an experimental stage at 6 months ; their consequences are included in the subsequent 6 month alteration analysis that follows. MEND shows that from 0-6 months mean BMI alterations in the experimental group n=71 ) were -1.0 ( -1.4, -0.6 ) P & lt ; 0.0001 maintained at 12 months ( n=42 ) -0.1 ( -0.7,0.4 ) although non important therefore exposed to opportunity mistakes. Physical activity additions were maintained at 12 months [ 6 month: 4.2 ( 2.2,6.2 ; 12: months 4.0 ( 1.09,6.0 ) P & lt ; 0.0001 ] ; nevertheless decreases in sedentary behaviors exhibited a impairment by 12 months [ 6 months: -4.8 ( -6.8, -2.9 ) p,0.0001 ; 12 months: -2.0 ( -4.3,0.4 ) p=0.1 ] .
Effectiveness of Interventions:
In drumhead, the LEAP GP brief intercession plan did non exhibit suited results in long term BMI, physical activity or nutritionary alteration ; and a subsequent larger trail[ 2 ]which used meta-analysis techniques to analyze both tests [ LEAP 1 & A ; 2 ( see figure 3 ) ] corroborates this. Some issues may be the ‘dose ‘ of the intercession being excessively low either in clip or frequence ; nevertheless, consideration of the costs of GPs intercessions either in length or figure of audiences must be considered. In visible radiation of hapless results and documentation from a larger survey this attack would non be appropriate for policy and/or pattern alterations in footings of GP bar activity, which is in resistance to many states recent policy developments ( i.e. Wag: Obesity Pathway ) .
It may be that fundss would be better served directed at community based intercessions and GP clip focussed on intervention of terrible instances ( Wake et Al, 2009 ) .
Figure 4: Extracted from Wake et Al, 2009
LEAP 2 RCT in BMJ 339b: 3308
This is slightly supported by the results of MEND, whilst there is some concern with the abrasion in sedentary behaviors and little differences ( -1.0 BMI ) in fleshiness index steps at 6 and 12 months post intercession ; this was a comparatively little test that fell below power demands in the chief experimental group ( n= 37 ; n=40 required ) . This may impose some concern at the acceptableness of the intercession and whilst being a community focussed intercession it falls some manner short of offering clear socio-ecological demands for wellness betterments in its attack, it should be viewed as a constituent of a suite of intercessions ( i.e WAG: Obesity pathway ) .
In decision LEAP is non a recommended intercession for either execution or farther appraisal ; whilst MEND is a promising intercession, that is based on current best pattern ( NICE, 2006 ) , and warrants farther geographic expedition. At this phase it does non allow support for policy alteration and immense investing peculiarly as it is comparatively dearly-won in fiscal footings [ buying the intercession and staff bringing clip ] for a little figure of possible donees ( maximal 15 per class ) . Yet its congruity with current best pattern guidelines do take to an overpowering impulse for farther probe peculiarly in visible radiation of the trouble in placing suited experimental surveies in the published literature meeting these demands as shown in this reappraisal.
Campbell K, Wales E, O’meara. S, Summerbell C ( 2001 ) Interventions for Preventing fleshiness in Childhood: A systematic Review. Obesity Reviews ; 2:149-157
Foresight ( 2007 ) Undertaking Fleshiness: Future Choices hypertext transfer protocol: // [ accessed 16/02/2011 ] .
Greenberg G, Ganshorn K, Danilkewich D ( 2001 ) . Solution-focused therapy: guidance theoretical account for busy household doctors. Canadian Family Physician ; 47: 2289-2295.
IASO ( 2010 ) About Obesity. hypertext transfer protocol: // [ accessed 17/02/2011 ]
International Association for the Study of Obesity/International Obesity Task Force [ IASO/IOTF ] ( 2010 ) . The Global Epidemic. [ accessed 10/02/2011 ] hypertext transfer protocol: //
McCallum Z. Wake M. Gerner B. Baur LA. Gibbons K. Gold L. Gunn J. Harris C. Naughton G. Riess C. Sanci L. Sheehan J. Ukoumunne OC. Waters E. ( 2008 ) . Outcome information from the LEAP ( Live, Eat and Play ) test: a randomized controlled test of a primary attention intercession for childhood overweight/mild fleshiness. International Journal of Obesity. 31 ( 4 ) :630-6, 2007.
National Obesity Observatory, 2011. Causes of Obesity. hypertext transfer protocol: // [ accessed 16/02/2011 ]
Pinhas-Hamiel O, Zeitler P ( 2000 ) Who is the Wise Man? – The One who Foresees Consequences ” Childhood Obesity, New associated comorbidity and bar. Preventive Medicine ; 31:702-705
Sacher P.M. , Kolotourou M. , Chadwick P.M. , Cole T.J. , Lawson M.S. , Lucas A. , Singhal A. ( 2010 ) . Randomized controlled test of the MEND plan: A family-based community intercession for childhood fleshiness. Obesity. 18 ( SUPPL. 1 ) ( pp S62-S68 ) , 2010.
Wake M, Baur L, granary B, Gibbons K, Gold L, Gunn J, Levickis P, McCallum Z, Naughton G, Sanci L, Ukoumunne O ( 2009 ) . Outcomes and costs of primary attention surveillance and intercession for corpulence or corpulent kids: the LEAP 2 randomised controlled test. BMJ 2009 ; 339: b3308 doi:10.1136/bmj.b3308 hypertext transfer protocol: // [ accessed 22/02/2011 ] .
World Health Organisation [ WHO ] , ( 2011a ) . Overweight and Obesity. Factsheet No 113. Updated February 2011http: // . [ accessed 06/02/2011 ] .
See table 2 in appendix 1 for inside informations of empirical documents reviewed but non referenced in chief organic structure of assignment text.
Appendix 1
Search Strategy Methods:
Inclusion standards
Experimental designs carry throughing the inclusion standards below were considered. Lone surveies published after 2000 were included. The ground for this was that the appropriate growing mention curves/BMI standard was published in this twelvemonth ( Cole et al, 2000 ) . More weight was besides given to documents published after 2007 as the NICE guidelines 2006 and the Foresight study 2007 were available to back up intercession design determinations. These comprehensive paperss identified the demand for multi-component intercessions.
Surveies including striplings or kids ( u18 old ages ) , who were classified as corpulent harmonizing the IOTF/IASO standards ( Cole et al, 2000 growing mention curves ) , or per centum organic structure fat.
Merely multi-component intercessions that included all of the undermentioned elements:
physical activity intercession
dietetic intercession
behavioral intercession
All scenes were considered i.e. school, community, leisure Centre, household, primary or secondary attention.
Merely intercessions that utilized suitably trained staff were included ; this could be a individual individual or squad attack and could include instructors, young person workers, wellness professionals, wellness trainers, research workers, pupils, exercising professionals, dieticians.
Result Measures
Anthropometric steps were the primary outcome step of involvement including:
Body fat per centum ( under H2O deliberation, tegument crease, bio-impedance )
BMI ( IOTF/IASO standards )
As a minimal these steps had to be taken three times:
Pre ( baseline )
Post 1 ( instantly post intercession )
Post 2 ( at follow up minimal 6 months )
Exclusion standards
Included over 18s and they were non analysed individually. Over 18s are considered grownups.
Did non include an anthropometric result step and relied on indirect steps merely such as alteration in physical activity, nutritionary consumption or behavioral purpose.
Had less than 6 months follow-up.
Unable to obtain full original text.
UK based surveies were preferred but non-UK surveies were non excluded ab initio, nevertheless, UK surveies would be weighted for inclusion more extremely for determination devising intents.
Systematic Search:
The undermentioned electronic beginnings of empirical research were used to place the documents:
MEDLINE ( inc MEDLINE in procedure )
Limits included:
English Language
Peer Review Journals
All Child 0-18 old ages
Randomised Control Trial
Full Text
Search footings ( Boolean [ & A ; ] ) :
The remove duplicates map was utilized which returned 101 abstracts for initial reappraisal for inclusion.
Management of possible inclusion articles:
Abstractions were briefly assessed on screen and possible surveies selected, referee was looking for similar mark populations in footings of age, sex, research design, fleshiness standards ; accepted differences included:
Theoretical attack
Initial appraisal resulted in surveies being longlisted ( n=22 ) and assessed further for relevancy, the full survey was downloaded ( if non available via Cardiff university they were excluded at this phase ) this left 12 surveies. The mention lists of these surveies were besides assessed to place any lost surveies of involvement and if they on farther appraisal were suited and available they were besides included.
This shortlislist was assessed for quality ( utilizing a 5 inquiry testing standards ansd quality appraisal modified from CASP RCT counsel ) .
High quality surveies that were comparatively closely matched in footings of age, sex, research design and fleshiness standards but that mis-matched on scenes and/or theoretical attack were included for concluding determination devising.
No abstracts reviewed
No considered potentially eligible ( longlisted )
No meeting inclusion standards ( and full text obtained )
Extra surveies identified from mention lists run intoing inclusion standards and full text obtained
Entire No assessed screened for concluding shortlisting. *
No meeting screening/matching standards
*See Appendix 2 for showing and quality appraisal standards
Table 1: Secondary screened documents run intoing inclusion standards ( n=2 ) .
General Information
Detailss of paper
Detailss of intercession
Outcome Measures / Results
McCallum Z. Wake M. Gerner B. Baur LA. Gibbons K. Gold L. Gunn J. Harris C. Naughton G. Riess C. Sanci L. Sheehan J. Ukoumunne OC. Waters E.
International Journal of Obesity. 31 ( 4 ) :630-6, 2007.
Outcome informations from the LEAP ( Live, Eat and Play ) test: a randomized controlled test of a primary attention intercession for childhood overweight/mild fleshiness.
The kids were between 5-10 old ages of age, and classified as overweight/mildly corpulent.
A two group test: experimental and control. The survey was suitably powered and suited randomization was in topographic point.
provided a short term ( 12 hebdomads ) low frequence ( 4 Sessionss ) minimal contact clip ( GP consultation/brief intercession ) attack which delivered a end puting intercession via a ‘solution focussed reding theoretical account ‘ ( Greenberg et al, 2001 ) designed for GPs with an educational/behaviour alteration subject applied written household support battalion. It was provided as a household unit in a face to confront session between the GP and the household at the GP pattern.
Primary result was BMI ( kg/m2 ) , secondary results included physical activity and nutritionary behavior alteration.
LEAP with a adjusted difference in average BMI of -0.2 ( -0.6,0.1 ) at 6 months ; and -0.00 ( -0.5,0.5 ) station intercession in the experimental group did non hold any statistical or public wellness important results in fleshiness steps. Whilst day-to-day nutrition at 6 months with a mark of 2.1 ( 1.3, 2.9 ) ; and 12 months 1.6 ( 0.9,2.3 ) were both significantly better in the experimental group ( P & lt ; 0.0001 ) ; the difference had begun to regress by 12 months post intercession ( i.e. decrease in adjusted difference of 0.5 ) , this had non had an impact on BMI alterations.
Sacher P.M. , Kolotourou M. , Chadwick P.M. , Cole T.J. , Lawson M.S. , Lucas A. , Singhal A.
Obesity. 18 ( SUPPL. 1 ) ( pp S62-S68 ) , 2010.
Randomized controlled test of the MEND plan: A family-based community intercession for childhood fleshiness.
The kids were between 7-13 old ages of age, and classified as corpulent.
A two group test: experimental and control. The survey was suitably powered and suited randomization was in topographic point.
provided a short term ( 10 hebdomad ) , high frequence ( 18 session ) , high contact clip ( 2 hours per session ) attack which delivered 8 x behavior alteration, 8 ten nutritionary and 16 tens exercising Sessionss. The behavioral constituent was based on acquisition and societal cognitive theories and curative procedures. It was provided in a group puting with two leaders and an helper with between 8-15 kids and their accompanying parent/carers
Primary result was waist perimeter ( centimeter ) , with BMI ( kg/m2 ) , physical activity and nutritionary behavior alteration as secondary results.
MEND with an adjusted difference in average BMI of -1.2 ( -1.8, -0.6 ) at 6 months post intercession in the experimental group did demo a important difference with greater BMI decrease in the experimental group from a public wellness position this may be less important as the mean BMI remained above the cut-off point of 25 denoting increased hazard ( 25.7 A± 3.3 ) and classification of corpulence ( IOTF, 2010a ) . Changes in physical activity and sedentary behavior were besides important between the experimental ( n=37 ) and control ( n=45 ) group with an adjusted average addition in active ( 3.9 ( 0.1,7.8 ) and lessening in sedentary -5.1 ( -9.0, -1.1 ) behaviours important t the 5 % degree.
Table2: Shortlisted documents ( n=13 ) ,
Reason for Exclusion
Maynard M.J. , Baker G. , Rawlins E. , Anderson A. , Harding S.
BMC public wellness. 9 ( pp 480 ) , 2009.
Developing fleshiness bar intercessions among minority cultural kids in schools and topographic points of worship: The DEAL ( DiEt and Active Living ) survey.
Not an RCT
Hofsteenge G.H. , Chinapaw M.J. , Weijs P.J. , Van Tulder M.W. , Delemarre-Van De Waal H.A.
BMC Public Health. 8, 2008. Article Number: 410..
Go4it ; Study design of a randomised controlled test and economic rating of a multidisciplinary group intercession for corpulent striplings for bar of diabetes mellitus type 2.
Dutch community sample: see if UK samples non available – Excluded in favor of Australian comparator sample in primary attention puting to let scenes comparing in reappraisal.
Shrewsbury V.A. , O’Connor J. , Steinbeck K.S. , Stevenson K. , Lee A. , Hill A.J. , Kohn M.R. , Shah S. , Torvaldsen S. , Baur L.A.
BMC public wellness. 9 ( pp 119 ) , 2009.
A randomised controlled test of a community-based healthy lifestyle plan for corpulence and corpulent striplings: the Loozit survey protocol.
Not measuring the loozit plan i.e. the intercession. RCT measuring attention deficit disorder on constituents to the plan. A twine design but non appropriate to this inquiry.
Marcus C. , Nyberg G. , Nordenfelt A. , Karpmyr M. , Kowalski J. , Ekelund U.
International diary of fleshiness vol:33 iss:4 pg:408 -417
A 4-year, cluster-randomized, controlled childhood fleshiness bar survey: STOPP
No behavioral constituent
Ash S. , Reeves M. , Bauer J. , Dover T. , Vivanti A. , Leong C. , Sullivan T.O. , Capra S.
International Journal of Obesity. 30 ( 10 ) ( pp 1557-1564 ) , 2006
A randomized control test comparing lifestyle groups, single guidance and written information in the direction of weight and wellness results over 12 months.
Campbell K. , Hesketh K. , Crawford D. , Salmon J. , Ball K. , McCallum Z.
BMC public wellness. 8 ( pp 103 ) , 2008.
The Infant Feeding Activity and Nutrition Trial ( INFANT ) an early intercession to forestall childhood fleshiness: cluster-randomised controlled test.
No results published, merely provide description of appropriate RCT
Flodmark C.-E. , Ohlsson T.
Proceedings of the Nutrition Society. 67 ( 4 ) ( pp 356-362 ) , 2008
Childhood fleshiness: From nutrition to behaviour.
Not an RCT
Warren J.M. , Henry C.J.K. , Lightowler H.J. , Bradshaw S.M. , Perwaiz S.
Evaluation of a pilot school programme aimed at the bar of fleshiness in kids.
No followup
Sahota P. , Rudolf M.C.J. , Dixey R. , Hill A.J. , Barth J.H. , Cade J
British Medical Journal. 323 ( 7320 ) ( pp 1029-1032 ) , 2001
Randomised controlled test of primary school based intercession to cut down hazard factors for fleshiness.
No behavioral constituent
Gately P.J. , Cooke C.B. , Butterly R.J. , Mackreth P. , Carroll S.
International Journal of Obesity. 24 ( 11 ) ( pp 1445-1452 ) , 2000
The effects of a kids ‘s summer cantonment programme on weight loss, with a 10 month followup.
Not an RCT
Martinez-Gomez D. Gomez-Martinez S. Puertollano MA. Nova E. Warnberg J. Veiga OL. Marti A. Campoy C. Garagorri JM. Azcona C. Vaquero MP. Redondo-Figuero C. Delgado M. Martinez JA. Garcia-Fuentes M. Moreno LA. Marcos A.
BMC Public Health. 9:414, 2009.
Design and rating of a intervention programme for Spanish striplings with fleshy and fleshiness. The EVASYON Study.
Not an RCT
McCallum Z. Wake M. Gerner B. Baur LA. Gibbons K. Gold L. Gunn J. Harris C. Naughton G. Riess C. Sanci L. Sheehan J. Ukoumunne OC. Waters E.
International Journal of Obesity. 31 ( 4 ) :630-6, 2007.
Outcome informations from the LEAP ( Live, Eat and Play ) test: a randomized controlled test of a primary attention intercession for childhood overweight/mild fleshiness.
INCLUDED: met all testing standards and provided an suitably described RCT and intercession with 12 months follow-up in a primary attention puting
Sacher P.M. , Kolotourou M. , Chadwick P.M. , Cole T.J. , Lawson M.S. , Lucas A. , Singhal A.
Obesity. 18 ( SUPPL. 1 ) ( pp S62-S68 ) , 2010.
Randomized controlled test of the MEND plan: A family-based community intercession for childhood obesty.
INCLUDED: met all testing standards and provided an suitably described RCT and intercession with 12 months follow-up in a community puting

Warning! This essay is not original. Get 100% unique essay within 45 seconds!


We can write your paper just for 11.99$

i want to copy...

This essay has been submitted by a student and contain not unique content

People also read