Scientific and Ethical Considerations of DNA testing

Published: 2020-07-24 22:10:04
2264 words
8 pages
printer Print
essay essay

Category: Medical

Type of paper: Essay

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Hey! We can write a custom essay for you.

All possible types of assignments. Written by academics

Deoxyribonucleic acid Testing ; Scientific and Ethical Considerations.
Deoxyribonucleic acid testing was foremost used in the 1970s. It is when DNA is taken from a topic and so tested utilizing different techniques developed over the old ages to map out the sequences and utilize the information in a assortment of ways, like provide information on a individual ‘s implicit in familial make-up or genotype. Deoxyribonucleic acid trials have developed from early Deoxyribonucleic acid proving to foretelling the development of familial upsets, testing for traits and population showing to supply penetration into future conditions and wellness of the individual, corroborating and endorsing up clinical diagnosing, antenatal testing and DNA proving to hone in on the particulars of conditions and individualise intervention. ( 1 )
Methods for DNA Testing
There are many signifiers of analyzing DNA get downing with the earliest there was Restriction Fragments Length Polymorphisms ( RFLP ) analysis which used DNA fragments separated into sets by size to happen the difference between samples of homologous DNA molecules from different locations of limitation sites. The Deoxyribonucleic acid sample is digested by limitation enzymes and the fragments are separated harmonizing to size by gel cataphoresis. But this was replaced due to clip restraints and necessitating big sums of Deoxyribonucleic acid. ( 2, 3, 4 )
Another Method of proving DNA is Polymerase Chain Reaction ( PCR ) this analysis uses specific parts of the DNA strand to magnify little sums of a specific piece of DNA. The method uses thermic cycling which is the perennial warming and chilling make this Deoxyribonucleic acid is broken into individual strands and enzymic reproduction can happen of the Deoxyribonucleic acid, it uses primers which are short pieces of DNA fragments which are complementary to the mark part and with DNA polymerases select and amplify the DNA fragment and these fragments become the templet for farther elaboration so hence bring forthing a concatenation reaction which exponentially amplifies the DNA fragment. However because this method is really specific it can non separate between assorted samples. ( 2, 3, 4 )
Another method of DNA testing is Amplified fragment length polymorphism which uses PCR to magnify DNA fragments, but used variable figure tandem repetition polymorphisms to separate assorted allelomorphs separated by polyacrylamide gel comparing against an allelomorphic ladder. The sets produced were seen by Ag staining the gel. It is an easy and low cost method of DNA proving. ( 5, 6 )
Besides a method which is the most popular and used most frequently in DNA testing is Short Tandem Repeats ( STR ) and uses PCR to magnify the fragment and so uses short tandem repetitions and is used on extremely polymorphous parts that have short repeated sequences of Deoxyribonucleic acid, this rule works on the fact that people have different repeated units, so the STRs can separate between different peoples samples. The parts of STR are targeted utilizing specific primers and amplified with PCR and the Deoxyribonucleic acid fragments are separated and detected by cataphoresis. ( 7, 8, 9 )
Another method in this instance which targets the Y- chromosome markers on the male portion of the sample, which is done by the production of primers aiming polymorphous parts on the Y-chromosome ( Y-STR ) and allows the separation of assorted samples from male and females. ( 10 )
Finally there is Mitochondrial Analysis which is used for proving extremely degradable samples where alternatively of DNA samples being tested which are sparse in the sample ; the Mitochondrial DNA ( mtDNA ) is tested because there are more transcripts of this type of DNA in a cell. The forensic scientists amplify the HV1 and HV2 parts of the mitochondrial DNA and sequence each part and comparison individual nucleotide differences. This is utile because mtDNA is inherited and so relations can be used as lucifer mentions. ( 11, 12 )
Deoxyribonucleic acid Testing Uses.
These trials can be used to observe susceptibleness of one peculiar disease which may be outstanding in their household ‘s history. To demo any symptoms which are happening or the passing of this familial stuff to their off spring in the hereafter may happen. It besides can look at legitimacy of birth of a kid, and trials can observe more societal facets like behavior and sexual orientation. Deoxyribonucleic acid testing is besides used for paternity proving to measure the farther of the unborn kid or born kid, besides can be used to fit organ givers with receivers in transplant instances. ( 13 )
Deoxyribonucleic acid testing can be used by the familial council member as a beginning to happen out if one or both the parents of the kid are bearers of a familial upset normally done to households with a history of recessionary familial upsets who are holding or see holding a kid, the most common familial diseases which are tested for are Cystic fibrosis, Tay-sacs disease and reaping hook cell trait. This will impact the households in many ways so ethically is this right? Other utilizations are to name any antenatal hazards by proving the fetus for any cistrons which may predispose the kid to mental deceleration or physical impairment like Down syndrome which will hold an consequence on the parents to maintain the kid or abort. Another usage in kids is testing the neonates for diseases like Phenylketonuria and inborn hypothyroidism and this is done as a bar method to bring around or handle the kid at the earliest phase possible. Besides Late oncoming upsets can be tested which are diseases that affect grownups like malignant neoplastic disease and bosom disease, which are hard to trap point the causes which can be nature or raising, from the cistrons or from the environment like diseases that can be found that are affected by a alteration in one cistron which can give the upset like Huntington ‘s disease but in this instance can be tested for throughout life at any phase of clip. ( 14 )
Recently the authorities has made new enterprises to research more agencies of placing a individual utilizing different markers and bring forthing profiles like DNA fingerprinting which come from the consequences of DNA proving to place alone features of a individual which are further used by the legal system for instances of paternity and condemnable designation every bit good as in the clip of major catastrophes and accidents or in war for the designation of soldiers and civilians which have died. ( 14 )
Ethical Considerations
Ethical motives are guidelines to which many issues can be resolved to protect an person from being taken advantage of by anyone seeking to take information from them and besides creates morality to non harm anyone. The moralss in DNA proving significantly coincides with the medical moralss and the usage of personal medical information. However in DNA proving there are more of import facets of moralss greater than in merely protecting the medical information, because the cognition of familial information can impact household members because of the information of their wellness position disease hazard and possible transmittal to offspring which makes the moralss environing DNA proving a batch more imperative. ( 15, 16 )
For people who are DNA tested it puts their privateness at hazard that the information about them will be collated and passed on to the universe. For illustration if a Deoxyribonucleic acid trial came positive for a sensitivity to a certain disease so this information may be assessed by many and deemed hazardous to insurance companies, the authorities, possible and present employers, if you ‘re at school so the information may be given out to the instructors so you would be judged below the belt in many facets of school life, even Bankss may label you every bit high hazard this puts your confidentially at hazard cognizing that your Deoxyribonucleic acid is available to everyone. Normally the trials are done to suspects in a offense scene to fit the perpetrator to the offense so your Deoxyribonucleic acid is taken but whether you are charged or non your Deoxyribonucleic acid is stored for all to position and some sample are non required to be destroyed so will be available everlastingly which may impact your informed consent if you consented for your Deoxyribonucleic acid to be tested but were ne’er told it will be kept everlastingly. ( 17 )
A specific illustration of ethical consideration can be looked at in the survey of Huntingtons chorea.
Huntington ‘s chorea is a dominantly untreatable, progressive and deadly disease. The patient suffers utmost hurt, nevertheless when diagnosed the bulk of the load besides to the relations who have to get by with the mental and physical impairment of the patients whilst gaining that they and their kids are at hazard. ( 18 ) The nature of this disease is there are variable ages of oncoming therefore those at hazard will non cognize their familial province until after they have completed their household or the non- bearers have to wait until late centers ages before they can be free of any hazard of developing the disease. ( 19 )
So if anyone wants to happen out whether they are at hazard they need to acquire a Deoxyribonucleic acid trial done which in this instance is besides known as a prognostic trial but this trial causes some ethical jobs. First does the trial have a high per centum truth and is at that place any inaccuracy related to the trial. In this instance this trial is used by the patients to do of import determinations about their hereafter and so there is a demand that inaccuracy of the trial is known so that lives do n’t radically alter for no ground. To cognize your hazard factor and the truth of the trial you need to cognize that the trial is proving the right thing in this instance is Huntington ‘s chorea ever caused by a mutant at a venue genetically linked to G8 or is at that place other signifiers of the disease, demoing that proving for the G8 may be misdirecting. ( 19 )
Second is the possibility that when a individual is identified as cistron bearer they may non be able to get by with the load of this disclosure. But if you were found non to be a bearer so this trial will profit you a batch, nevertheless the patients who have been identified as bearer they may be deprived of hope of populating a normal life and may go down or contemplate self-destruction. ( 20 )
Research shows that the visual aspect of psychiatric upsets is high among those who develop Huntington ‘s chorea, ( 21, 22 ) hence a shown increased in self-destruction in some households. ( 23 )
So a disadvantage of the prognostic testing shows that psychopathology in the people who at hazard is caused by the cognition they are at hazard of Huntington ‘s chorea and non the primary familial cause and that uncertainness is better that certain cognition that you may acquire Huntington ‘s chorea. ( 24 ) However it has been looked at that early diagnosing will give clip for the patients to fix emotionally and financially so that when Huntington ‘s chorea symptoms occur they are cognizant and prepared. ( 25, 26 ) Overall depending on your position the prognostic trials may increases or diminish the prevalence of self-destructions. ( 19 )
Last the issue of the possible abuse of the information received from these trials. Chiefly the fact that the information gained from the trials will be of involvement of others apart from the individual at hazard so hence may take to complications. Like if the partner wants to cognize if there spouse does n’t desire to cognize if they have Huntington ‘s chorea. Besides if a parent is identified as a cistron bearer so the kid is at hazard and so they might non desire to cognize this information. But there is besides the scenario whereby the household member desiring the trial needs another household member to hold to be tested excessively, so force per unit area may be put on this household member to acquire the trial done. With regard to this other administrations like pension financess, insurance companies and prospective employers may demand this information before a station is given. ( 27 ) Similarly jobs may come before matrimony where one individual puts force per unit area on to the other to be tested or because of a sense of duty wants to be tested for the individual at hazard. ( 19 )
From these positions it can be established that there are many ethical considerations and that in this instance of prognostic testing that a codification of pattern should be developed, with regulations and guidelines like prognostic trials should n’t be offered to bush leagues or used in instances where a bearer is identified who did n’t desire to cognize. Besides those insurance companies and others with fiscal involvement should be precluded by jurisprudence from inquiring for information on bearer province. ( 28 )
Problems may be diverted utilizing selective reding techniques before proving, so that the topic is good cognizant and to the full informed of the significances and restrictions of the consequences and is proved with adequate support after proving so that it does n’t all come as a daze and that the individual is eased in and out of the testing and the new information and cognition which has been learnt from the testing. This guidance is needed so that proving is done with full informed consent and provided with indifferent and impartial and with no duties or external force per unit area and the determination is entirely theirs. ( 19 )

Warning! This essay is not original. Get 100% unique essay within 45 seconds!


We can write your paper just for 11.99$

i want to copy...

This essay has been submitted by a student and contain not unique content

People also read