The impact of national culture on management control systems

Published: 2020-07-23 11:10:05
2530 words
9 pages
printer Print
essay essay

Category: Management

Type of paper: Essay

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Hey! We can write a custom essay for you.

All possible types of assignments. Written by academics

In the modern-day concern environment, there are so many endeavors transformed into planetary administrations. And the globalization tendency caused a immense figure of companies to follow the scheme of amalgamations and acquisitions for development ( Busco et al, 2008 ) . This needful corporations to run subordinates in different states. As a consequence, direction control systems besides have been influenced by more issues than earlier and the direction control systems of these corporations have been paid much more attendings than of all time. Thereby, there is progressively figure of experts and corporations directors research these influences and want to happen some methods to guarantee the direction control systems of endeavors could exercise exactness and effectual maps. In this article, the chief subject is to measure the impact of national civilization on direction control system. Consequently, some correlativity facets will be included in it. These facets are: the function of direction control systems, the definition of national civilization and the different dimensions or measuring of national civilization, grounds why national civilization could act upon direction control system and the impact of national civilization on direction control system. Following, I will discourse and explicate these facets and so derive a decision.
Research and analyze
Management control systems
In the yesteryear, there were two sorts of traditional control theories: one of them was ethnocentric attack and the other was polycentric attack ( Noerreklit and Schoenfeld, 2000 ) . The former was simple perpendicular direction that from caput office to subordinates. While the latter set up a claim to go forth subordinates autonomy to pull off themselves ( Noerreklit and Schoenfeld, 2000 ) . Until 1995, a more perfect control model had been created by Simons ( Noerreklit and Schoenfeld, 2000 ) . St. simons ( 1995 ) brought frontward that the purpose of control systems should be:
to promote employees to originate procedure betterment and new ways of reacting to clients ‘ needs-but in a controlled manner. ” ( Simons, 1995 )
Other experts besides developed some theories about direction control systems. For case, there was a research about the cardinal points of the design of direction control systems claimed that direction control systems are contingent on engineering, competition, environmental uncertainness, and organisational size ” ( Chow et al, 1999 ) . In an endeavor, the usage of direction control systems is to assist organisations to heighten the motive of all its employees to work with the same mark which is to maximise the involvements of corporation ( Chow et al, 1999 ) . Nevertheless, some researches advanced some sentiments that we should handle earnestly. Experts claimed that the direction control systems ‘ design and the penchants for them are different transverse different states ( Chow et al, 1999 ) . And the cross-national fluctuation did non be explained by the eventuality variables ( Chow et al, 1999 ) . Then, research workers found some peculiar factors impacted the direction control systems ‘ design and the penchants for them in a specifically state. These factors were besides relevant nation-specific ( Chow et al, 1999 ) . If companies false to plan direction control system of it such as adopt unsuitable public presentation rating tools, this could do companies to do incorrect determinations that may be inconsistent with corporations ‘ aims and involvements. And the struggle yet may gnaw the morale of companies and lead to negative influence on local directors and employees ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Therefore, we need to research the national factors and how they impacted on direction control systems.
National civilization
Nowadays, there are a good figure of literatures about the multiplex civilization ‘ definitions and taxonomies ( Seaman and Williams, 2001 ) . Among of these, the most typical and successful research was the findings of Hofstede. The definition Hofstede gave to civilization was:
the corporate scheduling of the head that distinguishes the members of one class of people from those of another ” ( Seaman and Williams, 2001 ) .
As the most popular theory served for researches about comparative cross-country and the broadest and the most regular used by other research workers when they researched on the civilization differences, the five dimensions of civilization identified by Hofstede were another great findings ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . The five dimensions are: power distance, uncertainness turning away, individuality versus Bolshevism, maleness versus muliebrity, and Confucian dynamism ” ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . First, the mean of power distance is the extent that a society accepts about the unequal distribution of power in societal organisations ( Seaman and Williams, 2001 ) . Second, the definition of uncertainness turning away is the grade of credence of a society holds about hazard, ambiguity and uncertainness ( Seaman and Williams, 2001 ) . Third, the individuality versus Bolshevism refers to the extent members of a society dainty themselves as persons but non a portion of a group, and the sort of society members more likely accept: a loose or a tight society ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Forth, maleness versus muliebrity represents the grade that the values of achieve-oriented such as assertiveness, aspiration, independency, fight and male laterality ” are broader identified with than the values of modest and need-focused like nurturing, mutuality, service motive, quality of life, and equality between sexes ” ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Fifth, Confucian dynamism indicates the comparative importance of continuity, doggedness, ordered position, and thrift ” ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Hofstede researched more than 50 states about the five dimensions of civilization and assigned Markss to them severally ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . In peculiar, Hofstede ‘s theories about the definition and the dimensions of civilization were extensively utilized in researches on impacts of national civilization on organisations ( Soeters and Schreuder, 1988 ) .
The impacts of national civilization on direction control systems
As the globalization becomes an inevitable tendency and transnational companies become the chief organic structure of the current concern universe, directors paid progressively attending on the effectivity of direction control systems in different states. Specially, directors were interested in the transferability of direction patterns across different national civilizations ( Chow et al, 1996 ) . Whether direction control systems of a corporation used in one state could be every bit utile in another state or non is the chief inquiry directors meet. Because different people of different states have different national civilization, they have different penchants for and reactions to direction controls ( Merchant et Al, 1995 ) . Therefore, direction control system worked swimmingly in one state may neglect to run usually in a different state.
At first, we research a instance about the comparing between Norway with Australia and Singapore. Everyone knows that Norway is a state of European continent, and is a part which has really different cultural and geographical compared with Australia and Singapore ( Buckland and lau, 2000 ) . Because the populations of Norway are comparative more ethnically homogeneous than Australia and Singapore which are more like heterogenous societies, Norse civilization seems to be more homogenous, and Norway has more centralized, formalized and democratic industrial dealingss than Australia and Singapore ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Harmonizing to anterior surveies, in both Australia and Singapore, there is a important tripartite interaction between budget accent, engagement and undertaking trouble, and the interaction has an obvious impact on managerial public presentation ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . The inquiry is whether this interaction yet exists in Norway. This needs to see the differences of national civilization between Norway and Australia and Singapore. The theories adopted to research this inquiry were Hofstede ‘s civilization definition and five dimensions. Two dimensions of the five: power distance and individuality, were theoretically supported to hold impact on subsidiaries ‘ budgetary engagement ( Lau et al, 1995 ) . In high power distance societies, power were concentrated on superior and subordinates about no chances to take part in personal businesss. Workers were used to obey directors ‘ orders and seldom interact and communicate with directors. Thereby, the budgetary engagement grade in high power distance societies seems to be rather low ( Harrison, 1992 ) .But, in low power distance, power was distributed from superior to subsidiaries and an inequality was minimized ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Subordinates normally communicate with higher-ups every bit. Consequently, the extent of budgetary engagement in low power distance societies is likely to be high ( Harrison, 1992 ) . In low individuality societies, people pay more attending on organisations ‘ involvements than on involvements of persons ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . The characters of low individuality societies were collectivity-orientation ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Peoples concerned the operations of companies and depended on companies to feed themselves. They saw organisations as their lives ‘ background. Therefore, the grade of budgetary engagement of subsidiaries in low individuality societies is likely to be high ( Harrison, 1992 ) . However, in high individuality societies, people put more accent on persons but non on organisations. The character of high individuality societies yet changed to self- orientation ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Peoples were comparatively independent to organisations and higher-ups insisted programs made by themselves without dialogue with subsidiaries could be more perfect ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . As a consequence, the extent of budgetary engagement of subsidiaries in high individuality societies is likely to be low ( Harrison, 1992 ) . The Norse national civilization influenced directors ‘budgetary engagement on both the grade of engagement and the scope of engagement ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Harmonizing to Hofstede ‘s findings, the mark of power distance of Australia is 36 that is higher than the mark of Norway at 31 ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . In contrast, the grade of individuality of Norway is 69 which is at the in-between order and lower that the grade of individuality of Australia which is 90 ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Because Norway has lower power distance and individuality than Australia has, the grade of directors ‘ engagement of Norway is higher than the extent of Australia ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) . Equally far as the impact of Norse national civilization on the scope of budgetary engagement, due to the historical and geographical grounds, Norway has more homogeneous civilization compared with Australia and Singapore, and thereby fluctuations in the scope of budgetary engagements in the Norway seem to be smaller than in Australia and Singapore ( Buckland and Lau, 2000 ) .
Following, Let us reassign our eyes to China. In Chinese national civilization, a good societal relation is a cardinal point to measure the public presentation of superior ( Wong, 2009 ) . In China, society afforded a close web for people to protect and safeguard their members ‘ involvements ( Wong, 2009 ) . And this sort of webs could act upon Bolshevism and group harmoniousness ( Wong, 2009 ) . So directors in China normally see covering with societal webs as the basic direction issues ( Wong, 2009 ) . Through the research done by Meiling Wong in 2009, a clear determination had been found that the societal web of companies has considerable impacts on five countries: turnover rate lessening, ROE addition, financing/liquidity, public presentation efficiency, and productiveness ” ( Wong, 2009 ) . Consequently, in Chinese national civilization, the societal relation webs had impacts non merely on constructing interpersonal relationships and reenforcing teamwork taking to better direction public presentation, but besides could assist directors to cover with external uncertainness ( Wong, 2009 ) . To day of the month, there are more than 50 1000s transnational endeavors articulation in the Chinese market every twelvemonth ( Hartmann et al, 2010 ) .For these companies, the direction control systems of them must be designed after to the full and carefully sing the Chinese national civilization, particularly the societal relation webs of companies.
In the epoch of globalisation, about all endeavors enter the international markets for keeping and developing ( Kidger, 2002 ) . With regard to many US-based transnational endeavors, the chief inquiry for them is how to measure their foreign strategic concern units ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Multinational companies normally engage local directors to oversee a foreign subordinate. This required the direction control systems should be effectual. Besides the impacts of national civilization on direction control systems should be pay attending to. For case, harmonizing the theory of Hofstede, one dimension of uncertainness turning away in five dimensions influenced the control systems. A state ‘s civilization which has high grade of uncertainness turning away prefer to the control systems have detailed and unambiguous public presentation rating points ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . In contrast, a state ‘s civilization which has low grade of uncertainness turning away is willing to follow the control systems are more slackly with discretional fillip ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . Equally, the dimension of Confucian dynamism besides has impacts on direction control systems. The directors of subordinate in a state with the civilization has high mark of Confucian dynamism will be encouraged by a long-run concern program which could take to good develop instead than short-run of fiscal informations ( Devine and O’Clock, 2003 ) . However, a director in a state with the civilization has low mark of Confucian dynamism normally focus their eyes on the current fiscal public presentations. Meanwhile, all of other dimensions of civilization have different influences on direction control systems. Companies should plan different direction control systems harmonizing to the civilization of state their subordinates were operate in.
In this article, the academic background is the definition of civilization and five dimensions of civilization established by Hofstede. We used the theories of Hofstede to research the impact of national civilization on direction control systems. First, the apprehension of the functions of direction control systems had been presented and we found direction control systems played a important function in operations of companies. Following, we researched the definition of civilization and the step to sort civilization. After that, we began to analyze the relationship between national civilization and direction control systems. Through the research of the comparing between Norway, Australia and Singapore, clear differences could be found about budgetary engagement of directors and subsidiaries in the states. This was translated by the different national civilizations. Therefore, the first grounds of the impact of national civilization on direction control systems was found. Then, an illustration of Chinese national civilization about societal relation webs was advanced to look into the impact of civilization on direction. We found that the societal relation web in Chinese environment had influences in both companies ‘ inter administration and external communicating and dialogue. At last, through the usage of Hofstede ‘s theories, Devine and O’Clock researched all of five dimensions of civilization influenced the direction control systems of foreign strategic concern units of US-based transnational corporations. To reason, the national civilization has obvious impacts on direction control systems. So directors of transnational endeavors should carefully plan the control systems for subordinates harmonizing to local national civilization.

Warning! This essay is not original. Get 100% unique essay within 45 seconds!


We can write your paper just for 11.99$

i want to copy...

This essay has been submitted by a student and contain not unique content

People also read