The Importance Of Worker Training Commerce Essay

Published: 2020-05-21 19:31:04
4857 words
18 pages
printer Print
essay essay

Category: Commerce

Type of paper: Essay

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Hey! We can write a custom essay for you.

All possible types of assignments. Written by academics

Harmonizing to W. G. Horner ( 1998 ) , the definition of developing expands from developing straight related to the public presentation of official responsibilities to any preparation that improves single and organisational public presentation and assists an bureau in carry throughing its mission and public presentation ends.
Whilst, Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) stated that preparation is a systematic development of the cognition, accomplishments and attitudes required by workers to execute adequately on a given undertaking or occupation. It can take topographic point in a figure of ways, on the occupation or off the occupation ; within organisation or outside organisation. They besides postulated that the procedure of preparation and development is a uninterrupted 1. The demand to execute one ‘s occupation expeditiously and the demand to cognize how to take others are sufficient grounds for preparation and development. The desire to run into organisational aims of higher productiveness makes it perfectly compulsory to hold preparation of employees in the organisation ( Olaniyan and Ojo, 2008 ) .
In the point of position of Tim Lowder, he defines that preparation is a learning procedure that involves the acquisition of cognition, accomplishments, constructs, and regulations, which contribute to the changing of attitudes and behaviours of employees in order to heighten their public presentation. Training involves the instruction of cardinal leading accomplishments and techniques in order to maximise public presentation of employees and make first-class leaders in the organisation.
On the other manus, Dwyer ( 2008 ) defines that worker preparation is an big instruction or andragogy ” . The theoretical development and research in big instruction can be traced to Dewey ‘s Hagiographas in the early 1900s, followed by Knowles ( 1980 ) and Lindeman ( 1926 ) . As Knowles says, andragogy ” is the art and scientific discipline of assisting grownups learn ” . Besides that, Knowles ‘ ( 1980 ) Hagiographas on instruction besides provided guidelines for practician for the nature of grownup acquisition.
1.2 The Purpose and Importance of Training
Based on Avril and Magnini ‘s research ( 2007 ) , the intent of preparation is to avoid high turnover. These writers claim that some of the workers might vacate when no preparation is provided. The ground is it would be difficult for workers to better without preparation. High turnover can be expensive for the organisations to bear. They have to bear both direct costs and indirect costs.
Besides the intent of preparation mentioned above, Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) besides found that preparation can heighten and enrich the person ‘s capacity to lend optimally to the development of the organisation. Training provides employees with the accomplishments, cognition and aptitudes necessary to set about needed occupation expeditiously. It besides develops the workers so that efficiency can be increased by cut downing spoiled work, abuse of machines and physical hazards.
It is besides of import to hold preparation for workers because technological and structural alterations render occupations and accomplishments antiquated at such a rate that the slow reclamation of the labor force through the entry of immature qualified workers might non do to fulfill the demand for new makings, thereby increasing the hazard of accomplishment deficits that may deject employment in a planetary economic system ( Martin and Grubb, 2001 and Layard, 2004 ) .
Apart from that, people with low makings face higher unemployment chances in states where they can monetary value themselves into occupations, which consequences in a higher hazard of being persistently in low wage and frequently in poorness. Policies for initial instruction and grownup preparation can, hence, be seen as complementary to making-work-pay policies and job-search aid as respects to minimising the figure of people who do non achieve and keep the accomplishments required to command net incomes that bring them above the poorness threshold ” ( OCED, 1999, p.12 ) .
Another intent of developing for employees by utilizing big instruction rules is persons would larn when their perceptual experience of world is non in harmoniousness with experience ” ( Mezirow, 1977, 1981 ) . For an case, when a individual faces a quandary and crisis such as divorce, publicity, resettlement and loss of occupation, he or she would see this inharmoniousness ” and be more ready to larn. Furthermore, grownup instruction rule besides emphasizes on the ability of the employee to self-actualize during the procedure of acquisition ( Rogers, 1969 ) .
Last but non least, the intent of developing for workers is to avoid activities, intercessions or relationships that may convey others injury. Since certain facets of human services may affect hazard of injury or uncomfortableness to practicians ( e.g. , working with violent clients ) , simulated preparation and development activities may besides show a hazard to preparation and development participants. Every attempt should be made to guarantee the physical and emotional safety and security of all participants.
In short, preparation and development of employees is of import and necessary for an organisation, as Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) mentioned, The demand for improved productiveness in organisation has become universally recognized and it depends on efficient and effectual preparation. It has farther become necessary in position of promotion in modern universe to put in preparation. ”
1.3.1 Organizational factors heightening acquisition and employability
Although acquisition and the development of competences are necessarily single procedures ( Baitsch, 1998 ; B.V.D Heijden, J. B. M. Klink, E.Meijs, 2009 ) , they are strongly linked to the organisational clime and to societal acquisition procedures, which provide ample chances for direction in working organisations to ease the development of workers ‘ farther calling potency. Recently, more attending has been paid to the issue of how organisations differ harmonizing to the conditions and clime encouraging acquisition.
While most surveies focus upon informal acquisition of specific groups of workers keeping similar places in the organisation, Ashton ( 2004 ) applied an attack in which all classs of employees within a individual organisation were involved. This allowed him to derive more in-depth information on how organisational constructions shape informal acquisition. Ashton ‘s findings demonstrated important differences between employees depending upon their occupation. For some groups of employees, he found grounds for larning in comprehensiveness and in deepness, while for others ; larning appeared to be shallow and disconnected. Entree to and handiness of relevant information, chances to larn and to use erudite accomplishments, handiness of support and feedback of directors and colleagues, severally, seemed to be of import conditions that influenced both possibilities and content of informal acquisition experiences.
Skule ‘s ( 2004 ) research besides added new penetrations to the impact of organisational factors on chiefly informal acquisition. His work concerned the designation of factors most contributing to larning at work in different sectors, and revealed that organisational size and sector were of import forecasters for the proportion of larning intensive occupations. Large organisations with over 250 employees offered higher degrees of larning intensive occupations. As respects to sector, it appeared that oil industry, banking, insurance and commercial services had comparatively high degrees of larning intensive occupations, while retail, hotels and eating houses appeared to hold lower degrees of these. Furthermore, Skule ( 2004 ) found that entree to learning-intensive occupations appear to depend on anterior instruction, with higher degrees of instruction being more frequently associated with occupations with a rich reservoir of assorted larning possibilities.
Analogously, those who are good equipped in footings of formal instruction continue to bask better acquisition chances at work. This mechanism is frequently referred to as the ‘Mathew Principle ‘ : ‘ . . . to those that already had, shall be given ‘ ( McCracken & A ; Winterton, 2006, pp. 56-58 ) . The acquisition of competences in the workplace strongly depends upon the larning clime of a company or, in a smaller sense, a section ( Olbert-Bock, 2002 ) . Autonomy as respects to work procedures, communicating, co-operative constructions, attitudes of and support by higher-ups, every bit good as clip for acquisition, are indispensable factors act uponing larning clime, as has been shown in many surveies ( e.g. Bergmann et al.,2000 ; Jenewein et al. , 2002 ) .
Bettering the sum of larning in the workplace is indispensable as it is, in many occasions, the lone topographic point to broaden one ‘s cognition and accomplishments ‘ base. In general, vocational instruction systems neither provide nor prepare workers for a go oning vocational development. Therefore, an increased accent on keeping the currency of vocational pattern throughout working life has risen, and in many states, womb-to-tomb larning policies have been developed ( Billett, 2002 ) . Spie? et Al. ( 2002 ) , in their longitudinal probe, compared the larning clime in five companies, by inquiring both employees and higher-ups to measure the factors that supported or hindered larning on the occupation. In those companies portraying the highest employee satisfaction with the acquisition clime, one offered occupations with undertakings which were relevant for acquisition, and the higher-ups supported engagement and partial liberty of the employees.
1.3.2 ( In ) formal acquisition in the workplace
Until the beginning of the last decennary, larning was normally equated with formal classroom-based preparation ( B.V.D Heijden, J. B. M. Klink, E.Meijs, 2009 ) . Though the consequence of formal preparation on employee ‘s public presentation is sometimes dubious because of the deficiency of sufficient transportation to the workplace ( see, for illustration, the work of Baldwin & A ; Ford, 1988 ; B.V.D Heijden, J. B. M. Klink, E.Meijs, 2009 ) , formal preparation remains an of import scheme for organisations to guarantee their employees ‘ competences.
Furthermore, an of import advantage of formal larning prevarications in the fact that it can be officially demonstrated, and used as a human resource step foretelling workers ‘ employability. Informal acquisition has ever been valuable for keeping and/or increasing employees ‘ public presentation, but since the 1990s, its importance increased farther as it became clear that most acquisition does non happen in formal acquisition state of affairss, but chiefly informally, both in and outside the workplace ( Marsick, 2006 ; B.V.D Heijden, J. B. M. Klink, E.Meijs, 2009 ) . A Canadian study conducted by Livingstone and Eichler ( 2005 ) showed that 82 per cent of the respondents were involved in some signifier of job-related informal acquisition, with an norm of 6 h hebdomadally. Similar findings were reported in a survey among Dutch employees ( Borghans et al. , 2006 ; B.V.D Heijden, J. B. M. Klink, E.Meijs, 2009 ) .
Apart from results as respects to the clip dedicated to informal acquisition, Borghans and associates reported the alone part of informal larning to job-relevant competences. A similar result has been reported by other research workers as good. For illustration, Lave and Wenger ( 1991 ) examined the acquisition of tacit cognition, which is embedded in the work, and that merely can be mastered by active engagement in the workplace itself.
How can informal larning be defined? Informal larning includes incidental acquisition,
For case, larning that occurs as a byproduct of some other activity, and which occurs, even though employees are non ever witting of it, and which is non ever deliberately searched for. Marsick and Volpe ( 1999 ) proposed a conceptualisation that has been acknowledged by many bookmans. They interpreted the construct by indicating to six features: ( 1 ) integrated with work and day-to-day modus operandi ; ( 2 ) triggered by an internal or external jar ; ( 3 ) non extremely witting ; ( 4 ) frequently hit-or-miss and influenced by alteration ; ( 5 ) an inductive procedure of contemplation and action ; and ( 6 ) linked to the acquisition by others.
How can informal larning be encouraged? Although much informal larning happens spontaneously and sometimes even unconsciously for the scholars themselves, making appropriate workplace conditions could increase the sum, quality and results of informal acquisition.
2. Training Methods and Research Conducted on Them
First and first, one of the preparation methods for worker is real-time preparation. Based on Mendenhall and Stahl ( 2000 ) , real-time preparation can be defined as pattern in which an employee turns to assorted beginnings for information and advice as new state of affairss surfaced. Real-time preparation is normally usage on the exile ( foreign worker ) . The first beginning of real-time preparation is internet chat suites. A basic Internet hunt will uncover information that is helpful for the workers to finish their occupation ( Magnini, 2009 ) . The confab suites allow people to post about their job, concern or inquiry which can be responded by other people with advice and suggestions. Many of the confab suites are created by people with purpose of interchanging cognition with other people. Using this beginning, information can be obtained from persons all around the Earth ( Lee et al. , 2006 ) .
Another beginning of real-time preparation is repatriates. Harmonizing to Danies et Al. ( 2007 ) , the definition of repatriation is the return of an exile to his or her ain state. When exiles are send back to work at their ain state, they would be repatriates that possess great blend of cultural cognition sing both the place and host civilization ( Magnini, 2009 ) . With the cultural cognition they gain, they would be a extremely valuable concern resource. Besides that, current exiles are besides one of the beginnings of real-time preparation. Since exile is working at a foreign state, they can turn to other current exiles as a beginning of real-time preparation ( Magnini, 2009 ) . Research conducted by O’Reilly ( 1982 ) found that although the chief advantage of information from non-human beginning is convenience, the chief advantage of information from human beginning is information quality which should be better.
The following beginning of real-time preparation is local subjects. Cateora and Graham ( 2007 ) defined local subjects as people populating in their place state. Exiles can seek aid from local subjects for civilization advice when they face jobs ( Magnini, 2009 ) . The bond strength of both local subjects and exiles can be enhanced if they communicate good.
The last beginning of real-time preparation is CD-Rom merchandises. Presently, there are many CD-Rom merchandises on the market that are intended to assistance concern professionals ( Magnini, 2009 ) . CD-Rom merchandises can be categorized as real-time preparation devices because most of them possess synergistic capablenesss where questions can be made and information can be retrieved when needed. Adam ( 2002 ) mentioned that with promotion of current computing machine engineering, the customization and interactivity of these preparation devices are increasing.
Harmonizing to study done by Magnini ( 2009 ) , of all the beginnings of real-time preparation, local subjects score the highest rate of effectivity which is 7.7 out of 9 and it ‘s besides the most normally use beginning of real-time preparation. This may be because the local subjects understand the occupation better and able to supply more accurate information. After all, the local subjects have the experience. Equally long as the cultural diverseness between the local subjects and the exile can be overcome and they can swear each other, local subjects as beginning of real-time preparation would be effectual.
Magnini ( 2009 ) besides had done a study and found out that, the less effectual beginning of real-time preparation is Internet confab suites. The rate of effectivity of Internet confab suites is 5 out of 9. One of the grounds why Internet confab suites are viewed to be less effectual is information credibleness. Since you would non cognize the people you are chew the fating with, the credibleness of the information is low. Other than that, a poster in practical community may travel unreciprocated for hours or yearss which would be a job for people who need immediate feedback.
Apart from real-time preparation, another writer, Escardibul. J.O, Xavier. L.E. ( 2010 ) besides found out that developing affecting a combination of preparation and existent work. There are two types of activities that involve theoretical preparation and practical experience within companies: contracts for preparation and the working/training plans indicated in the old subdivision.
In contracts for preparation, which have been in being since the 1980s, clip dedicated to developing can non be less than 15 per cent of entire on the job hours and must be outside the workplace. Theoretical instruction and working can be in alternation or coincident. Participants must be between 16 and 21 old ages old ( the upper bound is non ever compulsory ) , and normally the contract is between 6 months and 2 old ages. Participants receive a wage based on the corporate understanding, but it must non be less than the minimal pay applied to their clip dedicated to work. Firms can fund the cost of theoretical instruction through the recognition system, but in that instance fiscal resources are linked to the employment publicity fund of the Social Security Treasury and non drawn from the preparation levy. ( Escardibul. J.O, Xavier. L.E. ,2010 ) .
The following preparation method for workers would be Support and auxiliary preparation activities ” ( Escardibul. J.O, Xavier. L.E. ,2010 ) .These activities chiefly concern research and invention enterprises aimed at bettering preparation and go arounding information about the preparation system every bit good as to assist persons to procure preparation, accreditation of competencies, and employment
On the other manus, Cranton ( 1989 ) claimed that by using grownup instruction rules into developing methods, there are four methods for workers to larn which are instructor-centered, synergistic, individualised, and experiential.
Cranton ( 1989 ) stated that instructor-centered preparation methods are utile in edifice foundation for the grownups who are still dependent, nervous and inexperient sing their responsibilities. Some elements of instructor-centered acquisition are inquiries, presentations and talks.
Another method described by Cranton ( 1989 ) is synergistic preparation method. This method concentrates on the communicating procedure among trainees every bit good as between scholars and wise mans. Some illustrations of this sort of preparation are team undertakings, treatment groups and peer instruction.
The 3rd method suggested by Cranton ( 1989 ) is individualised method. It is based on the premise that persons would larn at different rate and velocity. Based on Cranton ( 1989 ) , participants would be required to give immediate feedback to their trainers in order for their acquisition procedure to be facilitated. The most common individualised method, harmonizing to Cranton, is modular and computerized direction ” , which is highly-recommended for lower degree cognitive acquisition ” .
Last but non least, the concluding method that proposed by Cranton ( 1989 ) is utilizing experiential method. It is defined by the research worker as a sort of acquisition that takes topographic point in state of affairss where the participant is really involved in executing undertakings or larning by making ” . The Hagiographas of Dewey ( 1916, 1938 ) have its theoretical foundation. Some methods that have this sort of construct are function playing, simulations and games ” , which are instead similar to existent state of affairss but are done in a safe environment. ( Cranton, 1989 )
2.1 Professionals and Cons
Harmonizing to Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) , the advantages of preparation for worker is developing can cut down the work of the director in footings of close supervising. It besides improves the thrust, enterprise and quality of work of the workers therefore help them to be more committed to accomplishing the ends and aims of the organisation and this has the inclination of heightening effectivity among workers within the organisation. Besides reduces the work of the director, all this method besides can increase productiveness of the organisation, and the workers able to utilize right new equipments.
Besides that, another advantages of preparation is trainers can acquire engaged in the preparation procedure instead than merely directing it ( Dwyer, 2008 ) . The research worker is confident that the benefits that directors could derive from utilizing these rules greatly outweigh its booby traps. He added that the nucleus of the preparation trade is the art or scientific discipline of happening the right solutions and understanding them to the full ” . Dwyer ( 2008 ) besides explained that employees benefits through taking duty for, and going involved in, their ain development and the literature indicates this is the most effectual manner for employees to larn. Dwyer ( 2008 ) concluded that grownup instruction rules have all the right elements that enable the acquisition procedure to be really honoring for both the directors and trainees.
Bishop ( 1997 ) besides pointed out that most occupation developing give an advantage to workers who participate in it. This is peculiarly the instance for worker-provided preparation, particularly developing that physiques on the bing accomplishments of its receivers and that has the clear end of bettering workplace public presentation. The grounds is rather clear that workers who receive developing from their foremans are rewarded with higher wage, greater likeliness of publicity, and more occupation security. In add-on, some preparation plans that appear to take to successful outcomes frequently earn this differentiation by creaming. ” That is, suppliers of developing plans can carry through deceivingly higher arrangement rates and pay returns by merely acknowledging comparatively advantaged labour market participants and excepting the difficult to use ” ( LaLonde, 1995 ) .
Last but non least, workers and employers are non the lone parties who stand to profit from occupation preparation. Supporters of developing routinely point to the benefits that accrue to a broader public as spillovers from accomplishments gained or improved through preparation. Indeed, it is virtually certain that any given community or economic development program will do at least a little, if slightly compulsory and formal, bow towards preparation ” as a agency of bettering community wellbeing.
Therefore far, we know that developing bring forth a batch of advantages for us. However, merely like a knife which is merely a tool that can cut or kill, developing for workers have its cons as good.
Gilad Chen and Richard J. Klimoski ( 2007 ) claimed that although preparation is blowing company ‘s money since preparation is normally carry out within few months to 1 twelvemonth merely. Yet, the figure of hours of developing received by each worker in some company is simply 24 hours. This type of preparation might project uncertainty on how much a fringy betterment in preparation can impact or heighten worker ‘s accomplishment.
While, Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) besides pointed that experience is more of import than preparation. The worker with no experience had the trouble to do the exigencies determination. Even after extended preparation, exigency respondents are likely to be confronted with unexpected challenges due to unanticipated situational demands. In such conditions, respondents frequently must accommodate and improvize behaviours under conditions of high force per unit area and considerable personal hazard.
Dwyer ( 2004 ) found that grownups normally prefer to be treated like their age alternatively of being instructed as if they kids. They are by and large autonomous scholars who have their ain aims and life experiences. Therefore, they prefer to research activities and discover methodological analysiss for carry throughing undertakings that relate to them ” ( Dwyer, 2004 ) . Dwyer added that grownups have fixed penchants in working manners, such as working entirely or in squads. Therefore, grownups may be uneasy and dying in new learning state of affairss.
Last, Dwyer ( 2004 ) besides mentioned another disadvantage with the development and preparation of workers is the educational scenes that are perceived as negative and baleful topographic points for the workers. Harmonizing to Knowles ( 1980 ) , one function of the grownup pedagogue as a facilitator of independent autonomous acquisition ” , and the facilitator should non be regarded as experts or instructors. In order to make a positive acquisition environment, facilitators should esteem the values, sentiments and ideas ” of the grownup scholars. ( Dwyer, 2004 ) Adults who have a positive mentality would be more likely to be better scholars.
2.2 Problems occur due to miss of preparation
One of the jobs that would happen from deficiency of preparation is occupational accidents. World Health Organization ( WHO ) defined occupational accidents as an unplanned event, which largely consequences in personal hurts, the machines ‘ and equipments ‘ taking the knock or the ceasing of production for some clip. ” Harmonizing to Sari ( 2009 ) , occupational accidents may happen when employees are utilizing a machine or they are non trained for or while they ‘re working at a occupation for which they ‘re non trained.
Another job that would happen from deficiency of preparation is occupational unwellnesss. Sari ( 2009 ) mentioned that occupational unwellnesss are the physical and religious defects the worker is exposed to as a consequence of working overtime with regard to the quality and the executing of work, while working in the employer ‘s bid and having his/her instructions. Harmonizing to Ozcan et Al. ( 2007 ) , if employees do non utilize the appropriate action techniques while making occupations that require them to flex down, make Forth, push and pull tools, it becomes really easy for them to catch unwellnesss of bone and skeleton system. Employees should be trained about occupational bone and skeleton unwellnesss, hazard factors, early symptoms, intervention, mechanics of utilizing the organic structure in the right manner and biotechnologies in order to forestall this unwellness or seek early intervention.
Apart from that, Martin and Grubb ( 2001 ) and Layard ( 2004 ) besides mentioned that workers non having preparation or deficiency of preparation are most likely to come in non-employment because their productiveness has fallen below their pay. Layard ( 2004 ) said that, for those people who find it more hard to monetary value themselves into occupations, developing provide attaining and keeping the competencies required to fit productiveness and rewards, hence assisting and prolonging their employment chance.
On the other manus, Olaniyan and Ojo, ( 2008 ) besides pointed that workers who fall short of preparation will be deficiency of cognition and accomplishments that they required in their occupations or responsibilities. The writers besides list some of the classs of preparation that can get the better of this job. There are basic clerical accomplishments preparation, computing machine accomplishments preparation, direction development preparation, supervisory preparation, and trades preparation can efficaciously work out this job ( Olaniyan & A ; Ojo, 2008 ) . The more inside informations to undertake this job by utilizing those accomplishments will be explained subsequently.
In fact, deficiency of developing non merely do job to employees but besides employers. Based on Scott ( 2003 ) , Chakraborty ( 2004 ) , Thow Yick, ( 2004 ) and Sharma and Talwar ( 2005 ) , deficiency of preparation will take theA outgrowth of dark leading and crisis within an organisation. As a consequence, the leader ‘s negative features, properties and behaviours emerge over clip. The behaviours and features of dark leading emerge over clip and frequently lie dormant over many old ages.
2.2 Ways to undertake the jobs
First of all, workers employed by high-performing constitution, for case, those belonging to more advanced organisation and those workers who need to utilize machine to implement their day-to-day occupation, longer continuances and more preparation demands to provided by company to those workers, which is at least 6 months to 2 old ages for them alternatively of merely few hours or 1 twenty-four hours preparation ( Sari,2004 and Gilad Chen & A ; Richard J. Klimoski,2007 ) .
Sing the job or disadvantages which is chance of exigencies in a day-to-day happening mentioned by Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) above, they have given a solution to work out by utilizing the conventional instructional systems design ( ISD ) theoretical account of preparation. This theoretical account of developing specifies that preparation should be focused on ”what is to be learned ” and ”real-world public presentation ” – what behaviors the trainees must exhibit in the work environment. They said one time these required behaviours have been identified, the KSAs ( cognition, accomplishment, attitude ) needed to accomplish improved behaviour on the occupation must be defined. Finally, a preparation plan must be designed to leave those KSAs.
Furthermore, Olaniyan and Ojo ( 2008 ) besides explain about an implicit in premise of the ISD theoretical account is that the KSAs learned in preparation will be used on the occupation shortly after developing. In this manner, the new accomplishments can be nurtured in the occupation environment. Instructional design rules have been developed to heighten preparation transportation to the occupation. Furthermore, developing rating in this theoretical account highlight the importance of finding how good trainees are executing on the occupation as a cardinal index of preparation success.
To better a worker ‘s cognition and accomplishments, Olaniyan and Ojo, ( 2008 ) are farther account to the basic clerical and computing machine accomplishments preparation, which basic clerical accomplishments preparation is offered through assorted media to supply employees a comprehensive preparation plan that concentrates on accomplishments required at all clerical degrees, while computing machine accomplishments preparation is offered through assorted media to supply employees with computing machine desktop application accomplishments from novice to advanced degrees.
3. Training Programs in Malaysia
4. Opinion and Decision

Warning! This essay is not original. Get 100% unique essay within 45 seconds!


We can write your paper just for 11.99$

i want to copy...

This essay has been submitted by a student and contain not unique content

People also read